Bring Them Down

(Taylor Swift voice): “Because, baby, we got bad blood…”

Bring Them Down

A long simmering multi-generational conflict between a pair of Irish shepherding families finally comes to a head.

Bring Them Down is the film debut of writer/director Christopher Andrews, and to paraphrase Durham Bulls' pitcher Ebby Calvin "Nuke" LaLoosh, he brings the heat and announces his presense with authority.

In 2024, the film’s world premiere was at the Toronto International Film Festival. Andrews has won the Douglas Hickox Award for Best Debut Director at the British Independent Film Awards, as well as the FIPRESCI Prize from the International Federation of Film Critics at the Mannheim-Heidelberg Film Festival in Germany, the award for Best Screenplay at the Rome Film Festival, and the award for Best Film at Fantastic Fest in Austin, Texas.

Basically, he made a big splash.

So…

Years ago, a younger Michael caused a car accident after his mother told him that she was leaving his father and moving away. The crash killed her, and injured his then girlfriend, Caroline, scarring her face.

In the present day, Michael is now a shepherd, living with his domineering and disabled father, Ray, in rural Ireland. Caroline, meanwhile is married to Michael's nearby neighbor, a rival shepherd, Gary, and they have a teenage son named Jack. Gary and Caroline are struggling financially after a storm destroyed a local bridge that links their house to the main road, basically sinking Gary’s heavy investment in constructing some vacation rental homes on their land. Jack overhears this, so in an attempt to help with his father's finances, he steals two of Michael’s rams and lies about it, claiming that he found them dead, when it reality, he has shaved off Michael’s colors, applied his family’s colors, and added them to their own herd.

But when Michael finds his rams for sale at the local livestock market, he angrily confronts Gary, who refuses to return them. The pair are kicked out of the market for fighting. They drive home in a rage, with Gary tailgating Micheal, who brake-checks them, causing Gary and Jack to swerve and crash into the ditch. Michael takes pity on them, and brings them home, only for Gary to threaten Michael and still refuse to return his livestock. Michael leaves, and Gary orders Jack to kill the rams and dispose of them, but Jack leaves with his cousin Lee instead.

Meanwhile, Michael keeps the entire encounter a secret from his father, but worried about Gary stealing more rams, against his father's wishes, Michael brings the flock down from the grazing areas up in the hills to the farm’s pastures. But when he gets the flock down to the farm, he discovers that he is missing one, so he leaves the rest in the pasture and climbs the long way back up the hills to find the stray as the sun sets.

Meanwhile, Jack and Lee have stolen a van. They drive to Michael’s farm that night, with the plan to cut off and sell the ram’s legs on the black market, mortally wounding the rams in the process and leaving them to bleed out. Michael returns to the farm, carrying the stray lamb, and discovers his mutilated flock, spotting the van across the field. Michael's faithful dog, Mac, goes for the van, and attacks Jack, who stabs the dog with his pocket knife. Michael finally catches up and chases after the van as it pulls away, leaving him behind. Michael is forced to slaughter all of his rams and his beloved dog too. When Michael tells Ray what happened, he angrily commands Michael to "bring me the head" of the culprit.

Armed with a shotgun, Michael heads to Gary’s place…

The rest of the story really needs to be experienced, I think.

As dark and maudlin as the dreary skies of Ireland above, Bring Them Down is a revenge story, but it's also a tale of the toxicity of bad blood, one that, interestingly, never allows for a simplistic hero/villain set up. Instead, it shifts perspective about halfway through the story, a kind of Irish Rashomon, and shows the perception of the whole terrible situation from both sides, the hatreds, the anger, the greivances, and all of the failures, basically all the things that push them into their corners and drives them to lash out. But unlike the dipshit complicit way “both sides” is used in American politics—as an attempt to excuse the malicious and entitled motivations of white conservatives, and the ugly tantrums of racism, misogyny, xenophobia, and bigotry they throw, by equating reasonable demands of equality from basically every other group in this country to their white supremacist bullshit–this is the story of little people, trapped in little lives, with little squabbles that curdle and grow cruel and ugly. It's a tale of how hurt people hurt people, and how that pain echoes out, creating more hurt people, until all these hatreds and recriminations burns them all down.

And much like a few other questions that come up when watching the film—like, does Ray know Michael caused the car accident that killed his wife, or even, who is Jack’s real father—while it’s never actually confirmed in the film, and yes, true, the specific inciting incident is pretty recent, it feels like this feud is something that's been going on for generations. There‘s an expected inevitability to their hate, and this is the base reason for everyone’s inability to grant forgiveness. It's not just a cycle of anger and violence and hate, it's an old cycle.

Mostly, this is a tale of fathers and sons and bad blood, one concerned with questions about the nature of masculinity, as well as a commentary on the way women bear the brunt of men’s rage. It’s a well told story, tense and containing some truly wild and violent shit too, but that's not the goal, it's not a glorification of violence, it's a lament for what the violence destroys. But the thing I really liked about this film, one of the things at least, is how it very directly addresses these problems, showing how the unwillingness to embrace humility and empathy is the natural end result of a society that prioritizes a hollow sense of manliness, where being perceived as weak is the greatest fear, but it doesn't try to provide answers. It just says... this is the problem, and there's no pat solution.

Good stuff.

Andrews apparently grew up in Ireland, caught between Catholic and Protestant families, and under very largely-looming family patriarchs, which makes sense, as you can see these experiences as the underlying basis of this story of young men struggling to find their place in this world, unable to escape the world they were born into, and doomed to become their fathers.

It's a sad story, but a great film.

But if I had one problem, it would be this…

Christopher Abbot, who plays Michael, is 40 years old. Meanwhile, Barry Keoghan, who plays Jack, is 34 years old. So when the film starts, it’s impossible to figure out what their characters’ ages are supposed to be, mostly because the film is clearly implying that they’re supposed to be separated by a generation, and maybe even, possibly, be father and son. But when you’re looking at them, they are also clearly very close in age. Seriously, just by looking at their faces, this is abundantly clear. They’re both great in their roles, but still, buying them as possibly father and son, or at least a good 20 years apart in age is something you definitely have to get used to at first. And it’s a struggle.

But other than that, this is a fantastic film.

Big thumbs up.